To WIN YOUR CASE, You Need to Know: What are THEY Thinking?

What is the attorney's strategy?

How does a physician avoid malpractice?

Can the insurer prevent a large payout?

Does the employer face worker issues?
Your subscription is your opportunity to view analysis and strategies from leading experts and practitioners. Each monthly report is an invaluable resource, a road map to winning litigation.
Current Issue: February 2016
Problematic Procreation: Liability Risks in Diagnosing and Treating Infertility

Click here to Login and read all 16 articles in this 50-page report.

Need this report? Click here to buy now.


Diagnosing or Treating Infertility: Liability Risks

Infertility affects about 12% of women between age 15 and 44 and about 7% of sexually experienced men younger than age 45 in the United States. 7.3 million U.S. women, or their husbands or partners, have sought treatment for infertility.


A variety of factors, including disease or trauma to reproductive organs, can cause infertility. Errors or negligence by health care providers treating other medical conditions may in some cases cause patient infertility. In addition, errors or negligence by providers in performing medical procedures to diagnose or treat infertility sometimes can result in injuries to patients.


Attorneys, physicians, hospitals, insurers, employers, and other potential parties to litigation should be aware of the types of lawsuits and other liability issues that arise in connection with the diagnosis or treatment of infertility.

The Perspectives: Improve Your Strategy


What proof is needed for a claim of lack of informed consent, alone or as part of a medical malpractice or negligence action, related to the diagnosis or treatment of infertility? And, what is a potential strategy for the attorney to employ?


How can liability for medical malpractice be avoided for an injury related to a patient’s infertility? And, what is a potential strategy for the physician to employ?


Can a payout under a medical malpractice liability policy be avoided by proof that the health provider was not negligent in connection with the diagnosis or treatment of infertility? And, what is a potential strategy for the insurer to employ? 


Can an employer be subject to liability for an employee’s infertility? And, what is a potential strategy for the employer to use?

Practice the Technique: Checklists


Check this list of facts and circumstances tending to show a provider’s liability for malpractice or negligence for a patient’s infertility.


Presented is a checklist of items a physician must consider when defending against claims of malpractice or negligence involving a patient’s infertility.


The insurer should check these “red flags” and inconsistencies when investigating a claim of malpractice or negligence involving a patient’s infertility.


Use this checklist to determine if the employee’s infertility is “work related” and occurred “in the course of the employment.” 

Expert Analysis

What Risks and Protections Impact Assisted Reproductive Technology Arrangements? 

Margaret E. Swain, RN, JD

What Legal Considerations Are Important in a Surrogacy Relationship?

Stephanie M. Caballero, JD


Alternative Dispute Resolution

Arbitration or mediation may be required by contract or statute, may be mandated by the court or, in some circumstances, may be the appropriate method for a negotiated resolution. 

Reasons To Reach Settlement

The following are reasons why the attorney, physician, insurer, or employer would want to reach settlement, and not take the action to trial.

Reasons To Go To Trial

The following are reasons why the attorney, physician, insurer, or employer would want to take the action to trial.

Jury Awards and Settlements

How much have juries awarded and what settlements have been reached recently in cases involving female infertility?

Medical Information


This section provides detailed medical information on infertility, the causes of infertility, assisted reproductive technologies, AMA guidelines, preservation of reproductive health, diagnosis, treatment generally and ART treatments, in vitro fertilization, artificial insemination, and surrogacy and gestational carriers. Also discussed is the prognosis and ability to work of a patient experiencing infertility.

Law and Medicine Resources

Law and Medicine Resources

Provided is a listing of law and medical resources for further information on infertility.  

Medical Law Perspectives
Other Reports

Malpractice or Negligence Liability: Thyroid Disorders and Conditions

Pneumonia Complications, Hospitalizations, Deaths: Risks and Liabilities

Risks in Caring for Patients with Cognitive Impairments: Alzheimer’s Disease and Dementia

Unclean, Unsterile, Unsafe: Risks of Injury from Unsterilized Medical Equipment

Scalpel Weekly News

Every Monday you get an email on law and medicine in the news: new case decisions and FDA, CDC, and DOJ alerts, warnings, and announcements.

Premium Scalpel Weekly News gives you access to all articles and more: medical abstracts, law reviews, news articles, or practice materials.

Current Premium Subscribers:

Or, you can register for only the free articles.

This Week’s Scalpel News:

Motion: Exclude Infertility Expert

Heart Attack During Finger Amputation; Conflicting Wrongful Death Evidence

Drug Approved to Treat Chronic Hepatitis C

Test Strips Give Falsely Low Glucose Levels; Class I Recall

Life Care Planner and Standard of Care Expert Excluded; Discovery Violations

Leaking Containers and Particulate Matter Require Recall of Baxter IV Solutions

Fibromyalgia Evidence Insufficient for Disability Retirement Benefits

Expanding Zika Outbreak Linked to Microcephaly and Neurologic Abnormalities